Should Music Have a Place in Our Services?

Music sparks heated debate in church circles. Yet we rarely ask the most fundamental question: Should we include music in our worship services at all? I’ve posed a challenging thought experiment to ministry leaders—would they consider fasting from music in their services for a set period? The reactions reveal how deeply music shapes our gatherings.

Music enriches worship, but it may also mask shallow content in our services. Consider an alternative: What if we redirected time spent singing toward prayer and Scripture reading? Would attendance drop? If so, that decline might expose an uncomfortable truth about emotional dependence in our worship patterns.

Guarding Against Idolatry

To be clear, I affirm music’s rightful place in worship. However, we must prevent it from becoming an idol. If the thought of temporarily removing music from our services feels impossible, we may face an idolatry problem. Our inability to imagine worship without music should prompt honest self-examination.

Despite these concerns, Scripture gives us compelling reasons to sing. The article “Why Do We Sing in Church? 5 Reasons” offers helpful insights:

1. We imitate and echo our singing God.
2. God has written songs for us to sing.
3. God commands us to sing.
4. Singing benefits our bodies and souls.
5. Singing unites us physically, emotionally, and spiritually as God’s people while witnessing to the world. As Matt Boswell writes, “singing is a means of disciple-making.”

Music as a Unifying Force

I’ve observed something remarkable about music’s power to unite communities. Each December, I notice tighter bonds in whatever community surrounds me. Holiday music creates shared experience across diverse groups. Yet after the season ends, that musical consensus fractures back into individual preferences. Unity dissolves for eleven months until the cycle repeats.

This pattern suggests music does belong in church—but we must ensure it serves as a healthy component of corporate worship rather than a substitute for substance. The challenge lies in maintaining balance between musical richness and spiritual depth.

Related Material

• Balance of Order and Spontaneity — explores how planned structure and Spirit-led freedom can coexist in worship, complementing your call to examine musical dependence.

---

Source: https://www.crossway.org/articles/why-do-we-sing-in-church-5-reasons/

Disclaimer: Information in my “slip-box” doesn’t necessarily reflect my agreement with the source or all its content. Recording diverse perspectives helps strengthen one’s position beyond the echo chamber of like-minded thinkers. By documenting alternative viewpoints, we engage in the intellectual wrestling match that ultimately deepens our understanding.

I aspire to post one note from my “slip-box” every weekday. If you want to learn more about how to work with knowledge, click this link: What is knowledge management?